How to use the Research Paper Critique Generator.
A critique examines whether the design and evidence support the conclusions. Distinguish limitations from fatal flaws and avoid evaluating unseen methods.
Make the workflow fit your task.
Compare the study's question, design and evidence with its conclusions. Identify what the supplied methods can establish, distinguishing limitations that narrow interpretation from errors that undermine a particular claim.
- What you provide
- A supplied research paper and critical appraisal criteria.
- What you get
- Structured critique of design, evidence, limitations and support for conclusions.
See the input and the result.
Illustrative input and output · a teaching example, not a live WebAct run
Example input
Study summary: eight convenience-sample participants tried a tool and reported finding it helpful. No comparison group or task-completion measure. Authors conclude the tool improves productivity for all teams. Critique the inference.
Completed example
Supported observation: the eight participants reported finding the tool helpful. Sampling limitation: a convenience sample does not establish a representative result for all teams. Measurement limitation: reported helpfulness is not a measured productivity change. Design limitation: no comparison is supplied to isolate the tool's effect. Narrower conclusion: the feedback supports further investigation of perceived usefulness in a broader, appropriately designed study.
Load this input into the prompt, then copy it to WebAct to try the task. Your result may differ from the illustration.
Decisions and troubleshooting.
Does a small sample automatically make a study worthless?
Assess the study's purpose and design. A small qualitative sample may support useful observations while limiting broader prevalence or causal claims.
Why does the critique evaluate methods that were not supplied?
Mark those aspects unavailable and request the relevant section. Do not infer unreported procedures from a brief summary.
Try it with your own source.
Replace the example with your material in the task prompt. Keep the requirements you need, then copy the task into WebAct.
Customize and copy the task ↑